Let us now look at what we changed and what we obtained. The table contains only findings that follow from the calculations or from the cited literature.
| Universe | What was changed | Main calculated finding | Weakest link |
|---|
| The Compact Cosmos | gravity 10 times stronger | stars 32 times lighter; the Sun's twin shines for about 1 billion years, small convective stars for hundreds of billions | small worlds quickly lose internal heat and hydrogen |
|---|
| The Grip | α larger by 10 per cent | atoms 9 per cent smaller, bonds 21 per cent stronger; water liquid from 57 to 163 °C; Hoyle resonance higher by about 325 to 400 keV (estimate) | amount of carbon uncertain, probably less than ours |
|---|
| The Beryllium Cosmos | beryllium-8 stable (a consequence of a small change in the strong force) | carbon forms in two ordinary steps; 98.5 to 99.9 per cent carbon in the stellar core | the amount of oxygen and water in the cosmos has not been calculated |
|---|
| Cosmic Islands | vacuum energy 30 times greater | galaxies form; growth of structure stops at 45 per cent; in the 30th billion years a few large and about a hundred dwarf galaxies are visible | loss of evidence about the cosmos |
|---|
| The Quiet Cosmos | no weak force, with accompanying changes | the stars' fuel is deuterium; composition agrees with the literature to better than one part in a thousand | little oxygen and nitrogen; radioactivity probably weak; short geological activity |
|---|
A few things stand out. All five worlds passed the first test. In each there are stable atoms and stars that shine for billions of years. That is indeed in line with Adams’s extensive reviews: stars are resilient to changes in the constants.
Every world pays some price, however, and it almost always appears in an unexpected place. Stronger gravity hits the lifetime of bright stars hardest. A stronger electromagnetic force barely touches atoms, and calls carbon into question. Stable beryllium eases the path to carbon and may endanger oxygen. The small, dense worlds of the Compact Cosmos die out quickly from within. It seems to me that this is the real content of the phrase “fine-tuning”. Hardly any constant acts on one thing alone. Each pulls on a whole web of consequences, and it is hard to guess in advance which thread will give way first.
The caveat needs repeating too. We have shown that the necessary physical conditions exist in these worlds, and in several cases that they are seriously impaired or uncertain. About the probability of life arising, our models say nothing.
Is our world special
Let us return to the question from the beginning. How far can the numbers of our cosmos change while it still contains someone to ask questions?
Five examples give no final answer, but they give a feeling. The range is wider than is often claimed. Gravity can be ten times stronger. The energy of empty space can be thirty times greater. An entire force can be absent, if two more things are adjusted. On the other hand, a change of only ten per cent in the electromagnetic force brings carbon close to the edge, and the exact position of that edge is still a subject of research. Our world therefore lies on a broad plateau with a few steep edges. The image of a needle on whose point everything stands seems too narrow to me.
It is also interesting that our cosmos probably does not offer the best possible conditions. In the Beryllium Cosmos carbon forms more easily than here. The inhabitants of each of these worlds could, from their own standpoint, write their own article about fine-tuning. The Groundlings would marvel at the fortunate size of their planet. The Waterkeepers would celebrate what little oxygen there is. The Lumans would not even know they had something to marvel at.
Everyone finds their own numbers natural
Here we come to a deeper question. Every observer finds the constants of their world as a given. For Isel water boils at a hundred of his degrees, because his thermometers, his body and the water he measures are made by the same, stronger force. The chemistry of the Grip, expressed in its own measures, is identical to ours. The change we see from outside is invisible from within. It shows only in the stars, where one force is weighed against another. It seems to me that an important lesson lies there. What we call natural is often what we ourselves are tuned to.
Conditions shape perception itself. The Groundlings see two and a half kilometres and think in nearnesses. The Lumans see one island of light and conclude that it is the whole cosmos. The Quietfolk remember only what they have counted themselves. All three pictures of the world come from the same laws, and each is framed by a different sky and a different ground. I think the same holds for us. Our picture of reality arises through senses, instruments and the epoch we live in, so it too is one window among possible windows.
On the pages of the Reintegration System we have written about the idea that the world we perceive is a projection of a deeper order, in the text The Holographic Nature of Reality. Our calculations neither prove nor refute that idea. Still, they show something related. The same basic laws, with different numbers, give worlds that their inhabitants would experience as complete and as the only ones possible. The difference between reality and the experience of it thus becomes a question worth asking from each of the five worlds. The answer stays open, and it seems honest to me to leave it so.
Do those other worlds exist somewhere? We do not know. Our calculations show what physics would permit. On whether nature has made use of that permission anywhere they say nothing, and no estimate of the probability of a multiverse follows from them. I think it is honest to leave it at that.
There remain a few questions that arose of their own accord during the work.
-
How many constants can be changed at once, and do their harms then add up or cancel out?
-
Is there a chemistry of life that uses carbon or water far more sparingly than ours?
-
What would the inhabitants of some more fortunate cosmos regard as the greatest shortcoming of ours?
-
How much about our own world do we still take as necessary, when it is in fact only one of the outcomes?
Five imagined inhabitants also left us something more personal. Garun lowered the beam and widened the foundation. Isel saved what was scarcest. Tavi broke the seal and wrote her name. Meda left accurate measurements. Nohu drew a line where his knowledge ends. Each of them lives with a limitation they did not choose, and each found within it a way to do the right thing.
Perhaps that is what conscious beings have in common in every possible world. The numbers of the cosmos set the stage. What we do on it remains up to us.